Michael Moore exposes Paul Ryan’s bank bailout bluster

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

buy this photo Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan J. Scott Applewhite/Associated Press file photo

Wisconsin Congressman Paul Ryan is one of the stars of Michael Moore's new movie, "Capitalism: A Love Story."

But you can bet that the conservative from Janesville is hoping that none of his constituents sees his performance.

In a section of the critically acclaimed examination of how Wall Street insiders diverted hundreds of billions of tax dollars into their accounts, Moore illustrates how the bailout happened. Democratic and Republican members of Congress who do the bidding of the bankers scared their colleagues and the American people into approving a massive bailout of the speculators whose misdeeds created the financial meltdown that shocked the nation in September 2008.

Ryan, the Republican congressman from southeast Wisconsin's hard-pressed 1st District, is shown playing the fear card by telling the House that it had to steer almost $800 million to Wall Street's sleaziest players.

"If we fail to do the right thing, heaven help us - if we fail to pass this I fear the worst is yet to come," claimed Ryan.

The statement from the Wisconsin Republican who has positioned himself as a budget specialist in the House played a significant role in securing support for a bailout bill that had not been adequately analyzed and that included few protections against fraud.

Had Ryan used his reputation and his role on key committees to aggressively oppose the bailout, he might have blocked the rush to judgment that economists now say could end up costing American taxpayers trillions of dollars - and a big chunk of their country's future.

Instead, the GOP establishment's favored point man on fiscal issues claimed - without benefit of facts, figures or any grounding in economic reality - that a failure to give the bankers everything they were asking for could bring on a depression.

"This is a Herbert Hoover moment," Ryan told the House, as he reached a fear-mongering crescendo. "(Hoover) made mistakes during the Great Depression - let's not make those mistakes."

It was a virtuoso performance. Moore was right to highlight it.

The filmmaker has given Wisconsin taxpayers a dramatic illustration of how it came to pass that we are bailing out bankers and billionaires at the same time that auto plants are closing in cities such as Janesville and Kenosha - both of which are in the 1st District. More importantly, Moore has reminded the voters of southeastern Wisconsin how key members of Congress such as Paul Ryan determined to take care of the speculators on Wall Street rather than working families on Main Street.

John Nichols is the associate editor of The Capital Times. jnichols@madison.com

Print Email


In Depth

Study linking vaccines to autism is discredited, but a local activist remains wary

The paper that helped trigger fear that a routine childhood vaccine might lead to autism was retracted recently by a respected medical journal, but Madison resident Mike Wagnitz still worries about vaccines.

Feb 09, 2010 | 5:00 am | Loading…

Advocates envision free fruit and nuts for Madison parks

As impossibly idyllic as it may sound, members of Madison Fruits and Nuts want fruit- and nut-bearing trees in a public place near you, where you can watch the fruit form and ripen and when the time is just right, reach up and pluck it.

Feb 08, 2010 | 5:40 am | Loading…

Things could be looking up for local manufacturer

Two years ago, Gov. Jim Doyle gathered with officials from an Austrian company to tout a new factory in Madison for manufacturing high-tech medical devices. Things have not gone exactly as planned, however.

Feb 07, 2010 | 4:00 am | Loading…

Will school districts drop sex ed rather than comply with state law?

Critics say school districts will drop sex ed entirely rather than comply with new state law

Feb 06, 2010 | 10:00 am | Loading…

Group of moms pushes vaccine in wake of meningitis death

Among the tributes sent to a website after Neha Suri, a UW-Madison junior, died of meningitis was a note from a Wisconsin mother named Gail Bailey. She is a member of Moms On Meningitis, which works to raise awareness about the disease.

Feb 05, 2010 | 5:00 am | Loading…

More Cap Times