Theater review: Brightly blasphemous ‘Book of Mormon’ high kicks into Chicago

2012-12-25T11:00:00Z Theater review: Brightly blasphemous ‘Book of Mormon’ high kicks into ChicagoLINDSAY CHRISTIANS | 77 Square |

Thank heaven for “The Book of Mormon.”

The cheerfully profane show has finally opened at Chicago’s Bank of America Theatre after months of hype. Local news outlets have reported that the run is sold out through March 3, leading to an extension — likely the first of many — to June 2.

“Mormon,” a 2011 Tony Award winner created by the “South Park” team of Matt Stone and Trey Parker with “Avenue Q’s” Robert Lopez — all three of whom were in the audience for the Wednesday, Dec. 19 opening — has inspired raves from critics and comedians alike. (Jon Stewart said on “The Daily Show” that it’s “so good it makes (him) *bleeping* angry.”)

What makes these Mormons so much fun is silly “South Park” social satire packaged as a traditional song-and-dance musical. Amid not-so-subtle commentary about white privilege and the preposterousness of certain religious beliefs are energetic dance numbers and several dangerously catchy tunes.

“Book of Mormon” follows two naïve young missionaries to a village in Uganda (“Oh boy!” Elder Cunningham exclaims, “like ‘Lion King!’”). After losing their bags to the local warlord’s minions, the pair is informed that they must keep the windows closed at night to keep out “the scorpions, and the mosquitoes … and the snakes and the safari ants which can plant their eggs underneath your skin and eat you from the inside.”

The elders’ training in Utah has left them somewhat unprepared for this.

The brightest star in Chicago’s production is Ben Pratt as Elder Arnold Cunningham, a variation on his awkward-roommate role in the fall movie “Pitch Perfect.” With no concept of social boundaries, a desperate need to be liked and a blind enthusiasm that makes his fellow elders cringe, Arnold makes his religion up as he goes along with disastrous results.

Nic Rouleau takes on the role Andrew Rannells (“The New Normal”) originated on Broadway. As the tightly wound Elder Kevin Price, Rouleau has an edge early on and speak-sings too often, even in his second act diva moment, “I Believe.”

But former “American Idol” finalist Syesha Mercado is perfectly cast as Nabulungi, a trusting village girl with dreams of “Sal Tlay Ka Siti,” “where flies don’t bite your eyeballs, and human life has worth.” As naïve as Cunningham, Nabulungi’s romantic duet with him (“Baptize Me”) is at once touching and mildly scandalous.

Choreographer and co-director (with Parker) Casey Nicholaw gives the Mormon corps plenty of goofy, high kicking, jazz-handsy dance numbers, led by Pierce Cassedy as the gay-but-not-really Elder McKinley. Cassedy takes a minor role and runs away with it, tap shoes clicking merrily.

Like “South Park,” “Book of Mormon” trades on a casual irreverence about the Important Things. Jesus appears in a robe lined with Christmas lights (costumes by Ann Roth); Elder McKinley insists his homosexuality is “a curable curse.” While Parker and Stone draw on real tenets of the church, if anything, Mormonism seems less comprehensible by the end of the show.

But “Book of Mormon’s” ultimate message, while deliciously subversive, remains hopeful. Uganda changes the elders, and they, incredibly, change it.

Take out the naughty words and the sexual innuendo, and “Mormon” has a heart of pure gold.

Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

No Comments Posted.

We provide a valuable forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on posted articles. But there are rules: Don't promote products or services, impersonate other site users, register multiple accounts, threaten or harass others, post vulgar, abusive, obscene or sexually oriented language. Don't post content that defames or degrades anyone. Don't repost copyrighted material; link to it. In other words, stick to the topic and play nice. Report abuses by clicking the button. Users who break the rules will be banned from commenting. We no longer issue warnings.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

What to do and see in Madison sent to your inbox

Receive an email featuring free tickets to concerts, shows and more.

Get the latest movie buzz, led by The Cap Times' Rob Thomas

Get entertainment highlights & reviews from the staffs at the WSJ and Cap Times.

Get food & drink news and reviews from the WSJ and Cap Times staffs.