Restaurant review

Hy-Vee Market Cafe makes you forget you're eating in a grocery store

2013-07-07T08:25:00Z Hy-Vee Market Cafe makes you forget you're eating in a grocery storeSAMARA KALK DERBY | Wisconsin State Journal | skalk@madison.com | 608-252-6439 madison.com

The East Side Hy-Vee has been open for four years already, and while it is a beautiful store, its restaurant is the poor cousin of the one in the bigger, more upscale West Side grocery store that helped revitalize Westgate shopping center when it opened in May.

The biggest differences are that the dining room in Westgate’s “Market Cafe” offers booths, waitstaff, beer and wine.

Unlike the East Washington location, customers can order off a menu available at the tables. The other option is to pick out food immediately from behind glass cases — mostly Italian and Asian — and self-service from a well-stocked, gorgeous-looking salad bar.

Instead of paying before eating like you do on the East Side, your server gives you a bill that is handled tableside.

Hy-Vee’s politely named “all-you-care-to-eat” salad bar has a price tag of $7.99. One-trip and to-go portions are less expensive.

Most impressive is the huge amount of fresh, pristine fruit, all cut and ready to eat. On a recent visit, it included bright red strawberries, watermelon chunks, mango slices, pineapple, blueberries, raspberries, blackberries, pink grapefruit, green and red grapes, kiwi, honeydew melon and cantaloupe. I’m probably leaving something out.

A friend mentioned that they stocked papaya the first week but may have discontinued it because of a lack of interest.

The weekday we stopped in for lunch, the watermelon wasn’t ripe and the raspberries were nearly tasteless. And the mango was preserved in something acidic. But it all looked tantalizing.

It’s also encouraging that Hy-Vee offers a variety of lettuce options as well as kale salad with red onions and pepitas in a light oil and vinegar dressing.

Kale, by the way, is a wonder food with more iron than beef, more calcium than milk, and 10 times more vitamin C than spinach. That’s according to a University of New Hampshire publication. Prepare it the right way and it can taste amazing.

At Hy-Vee, I perked up a plate of kale with blue cheese, strips of crisp yellow bell peppers, mushrooms and real crumbled up bacon instead of bacon bits.

The best pre-made salad on the salad bar was the cavatapi pasta salad with a liberal amount of pesto. The pre-made salads change all the time, which is probably appreciated by regular customers.

Also worthwhile were the sweet pickled beets with onion, and the creamy cucumber salad with thinly sliced cukes.

A dining companion went with the Chinese menu and had chicken with broccoli ($5.49). He was impressed with the amount of food for the price, but the mound of fried rice had little flavor. The two main ingredients were fine, but Hy-Vee isn’t the first place I’d go if I were in the mood for Chinese food. The meal came complete with a decent-tasting chicken egg roll and a wrapped-up fortune cookie.

Speaking of desserts, there were a number of mousses or whips on the salad bar, with the cookies-and-cream one scoring big at our table.

My daughter, who has taken a number of excellent Hy-Vee cooking classes on the East Side and has always enjoyed the grocery’s pizza, had a slice of cheese pizza ($1.99) and was more than happy. Kids drinks are free, and customers can choose their soft drink from one of those fancy new, all-in-one soda fountains.

Service was surprisingly friendly and helpful. One server brought us water glasses with lemon, and another checked on us regularly and cleared away all plates.

The restaurant with its sliding glass entryway has comfortable booths, but on our visit it was overly air-conditioned.

I recently took some out-of-town visitors to dinner at the East Side location and they never let me forget we were eating in a grocery store. At the new West Side “Market Cafe,” once you are seated, the grocery part slips away.

Copyright 2015 madison.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(2) Comments

  1. Laudmauth
    Report Abuse
    Laudmauth - July 05, 2013 7:28 pm
    So the Salad Bar pricing goes like this:
    $2.99 for the small plate
    $4.99 per lb to go
    $5.99 for the large plate
    $7.99 for All You Can Eat

    Due to my superior intellect and extreme powers of observation, I was able to sort out that mess in just under 20 minutes by carefully studying the various signs.
    The pricing games they play at High Vee make the Price is Right look like a game show. "Buy 2 of these and get 10 cents a gallon off"
    "Buy This Item Today and get 5 cents a gallon off".

    Difficult to know if the prices are good or the gas discount sufficient to make it a good deal.
  2. midwestguy
    Report Abuse
    midwestguy - July 05, 2013 1:46 pm
    While the deli itself has some nice items to take back to the table, the actual menu in the sit down area is pretty pedestrian.

We provide a valuable forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on posted articles. But there are rules: Don't promote products or services, impersonate other site users, register multiple accounts, threaten or harass others, post vulgar, abusive, obscene or sexually oriented language. Don't post content that defames or degrades anyone. Don't repost copyrighted material; link to it. In other words, stick to the topic and play nice. Report abuses by clicking the button. Users who break the rules will be banned from commenting. We no longer issue warnings.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

What to do and see in Madison sent to your inbox

Receive an email featuring free tickets to concerts, shows and more.


Get the latest movie buzz, led by The Cap Times' Rob Thomas


Get entertainment highlights & reviews from the staffs at the WSJ and Cap Times.

Get food & drink news and reviews from the WSJ and Cap Times staffs.