Senate candidate Thompson has name recognition, but does his long legacy help or hurt?

GOP SENATE PRIMARY | FOURTH OF A FIVE-PART SERIES
2012-07-29T07:45:00Z 2012-09-14T20:17:17Z Senate candidate Thompson has name recognition, but does his long legacy help or hurt?DOUG ERICKSON | Wisconsin State Journal | derickson@madison.com | 608-252-6149 madison.com

Tommy Thompson, the former four-term Wisconsin governor, strode through the midway at the Jefferson County Fair earlier this month, approaching strangers with a "How ya' doin'?"

Some fair-goers, briefly unsure of the man before them, quickly figured it out.

"Hey, I recognize you," said Glen Balis, a smile spreading across his face. Balis, a general laborer from Edgerton, said later he intends to vote for Thompson in the Republican U.S. Senate primary Aug. 14 because of Thompson's accomplishments as governor.

This is the kind of interaction Thompson relishes. In an interview, he spoke of his name recognition with pride and some braggadocio.

"Eighty-eight percent of the people in this state still know me," said Thompson, 70, who was U.S. secretary of health and human services under President George W. Bush. "And they don't know me as governor or secretary or Mr. Thompson. They know me as Tommy. I don't know of any person — Democrat or Republican — running any place in the United States for a statewide office that can use just their first name."

Thompson now finds himself in the curious position of defending his name — and his legacy — against critics in his own party. He's a Washington insider, they say, a closet moderate who layered on government spending as governor.

When he first ran for that post in 1986, detractors in his party derided him as too conservative to be elected statewide. Now, some say he's not conservative enough.

"Isn't that amazing?" said Thompson, clearly irked by the attacks. "I'll prove them wrong again."

Back in the fray

Thompson has never lost a statewide race, but his hold on this one appears increasingly tenuous. Once comfortably ahead in the polls, he's fending off Madison businessman Eric Hovde, a political newcomer who has pulled close in a couple of polls after spending millions of his own money.

Former U.S. Rep. Mark Neumann and state Assembly speaker Jeff Fitzgerald also are in the Republican primary. The winner will face Democratic U.S. Rep. Tammy Baldwin on Nov. 6.

Thompson won't say how much of his own money he's spending on the race, other than "more than I thought I would." He pointedly says he has "the kind of popularity that money can't buy, because it's been earned through hard work."

Two years ago, he passed on challenging then-U.S. Sen. Russ Feingold. What changed? "My family was not in favor of me running then. They are today."

The extended Thompson family had a fuller plate in 2010 with pregnancies and newborns, and they wouldn't have had as much time to campaign, said daughter Tommi Thompson, 41, the middle of Thompson's three children.

She is finance and operations director for the Wisconsin Women's Health Foundation, started in 1997 by her mother, Sue Ann Thompson. The three Thompson siblings, all of whom campaigned with their father at the Jefferson County Fair, have eight children among them.

Since 2010, the country's debt has increased and the economy hasn't ignited, said Jason Thompson, 37, a Milwaukee attorney. "We all realize the country is in a financial disaster, and we think Dad is the best one to address it."

Added oldest sibling Kelli Thompson, 42, who heads the State Public Defender's Office: "The minute he didn't run two years ago, I think he regretted it. This is his passion."

A state institution

Thompson already had served 20 years in the state Assembly when he won the governorship in 1986. During his unprecedented four terms, he converted the state's welfare system from an entitlement to a jobs program, launched a public school voucher program, revamped education funding and helped create BadgerCare for poor families needing health care.

"He's a practical conservative," said Jim Mack, 73, a Beaver Dam attorney who has been friends with Thompson since training with him on the UW-Madison boxing team. "He isn't just against things. He figures out how to solve problems." (Thompson boxed at a sinewy 135 pounds and "could really take a punch," Mack said.)

Asked to pluck out an achievement he's most proud of, Thompson goes for one sure to appeal to GOP primary voters: "Ninety-one tax cuts, more than any other governor in the country, I believe."

With two years remaining in his fourth term, Thompson left Wisconsin to join Bush's Cabinet. Nine months into his federal post, terrorists struck New York City, thrusting Thompson onto the world stage as an anthrax scare swept the country.

Private sector work

Thompson left his federal post in 2005 after four years. He launched a brief, poorly received campaign for the 2008 Republican presidential nomination but mainly has been amassing lucrative corporate positions that critics label a cash grab. He has assets of more than $13 million, according to his federal financial disclosure form.

He has shed many of his private-sector positions, including the presidency of Logistics Health Inc., which provides health care to military personnel. He had spent about one-third of his time there, he said.

Earlier this year, he left the D.C. law firm of Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld, where he'd been a partner. He remains the chairman of three companies and sits on the boards of four others, he said.

Thompson makes no apologies for his private-sector salaries. Using income from speeches, he completed a new house four years ago on his farm near Elroy in Juneau County, about 85 miles northwest of Madison.

Thompson grew up in the city of Elroy, the son of a grocery store owner and teacher. His grandparents lived on the farm then.

He now grows corn, soybeans and hay on 700 acres there and raises a herd of about 100 Belted Galloway cows. A family friend handles day-to-day operations.

Thompson and his wife, Sue Ann, have been married 43 years. They've made Madison their primary residence since 2001, when they bought a new house on Madison's Far East Side for $353,900. The couple also own a year-round home on Lake Wisconsin.

Looking ahead

If elected, Thompson would be 77 when his first Senate term ends. He bats away health questions with mild irritation, saying he's mentally and physically strong. He'd consider a second Senate term if the country's problems aren't fixed in six years, he said.

He does 100 pushups every day — one set of 50 in the morning, another set at night. He walked more than 10 miles in 100-degree heat in four parades on July 4.

"There's nothing he used to do that he can't do now," said Sue Ann Thompson, 70, who works full time at the foundation she started. "He goes up to our farm and can spend 12 hours a day planting corn or tagging cows."

She didn't really expect her husband to be on the campaign trail again, she said. But knowing the seriousness of the country's problems and how dedicated her husband is to Wisconsin, "I told him to go for it," she said. "You have to live your dreams."

Copyright 2015 madison.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(13) Comments

  1. Tpartywarrior
    Report Abuse
    Tpartywarrior - July 30, 2012 11:38 am
    ABB---Anybody But Baldwin

    Tammy is a nice person but will run as a centrist even though she is a further left extremist than Nancy Pelosi.
  2. FearorLove
    Report Abuse
    FearorLove - July 30, 2012 6:21 am
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZWi2hEvkRc&feature=youtu.be
  3. Big_Joe
    Report Abuse
    Big_Joe - July 29, 2012 8:55 pm
    Jim: Don't be so quick to condemn Hovde. After all, his family roots are in Madison and, during his residence in DC, I'm not sure he should even have much of an interest in Wisconsin Politics. It's easy to dismiss him as a vulture capitalist, but he seems to bring some talents that are in short supply these days, and I, for one, think his message is on point. In the end, I think the nomination will go to Tommy in a squeaker, but I won't be shocked if Hovde pulls it off.
  4. tomtom33
    Report Abuse
    tomtom33 - July 29, 2012 3:44 pm
    I can't believe I'm writing this. I don't like Tommy. However, he was not and is not stupid. He has a lot of faults. But those faults were all well known before he ran for Governor the first time. And he kept winning.

    He is a career politician, a consummate politician. I do like Tammy, but Tommy could accomplish a whole lot more for Wisconsin than Tammy could.
  5. pmbalele
    Report Abuse
    pmbalele - July 29, 2012 1:55 pm
    Thanks God Tommy is tied in the poll with Tammy. The state of Wisconsin should never vote for Tommy Thompson. Look what he says on TV: "I will reduce federal deficit; overturn ObamaCare and blah, blah." Thompson is old, a liar and hypocrite. Thompson is the same guy who caused the deficit while governor of Wisconsin. I should have sued Tommy and put in him in prison for corruption. The guy bribed law makers by giving them state classified jobs – just to get rid of them as opponents. Some of these lawmakers complained to me that after they left their positions in legislature to take civil position in exchange, Tommy dumped them. People also don’t know Tommy hired many whacky girl-friends and beer friends some even could not write English or work. Tommy is the same guy who abandoned his wife – didn’t invite her to live with him at state house. Tommy got $11 mi fed contract to service veterans, but squandered the money. I should have put Tommy in prison for his corruption. Wisconsin – please be careful with this sleek guy – a career politician and not smart.
  6. Kevin
    Report Abuse
    Kevin - July 29, 2012 9:13 am
    Yes, Tommy's past will hurt him, and the libs are going to recall Governor Walker.

    The progressives just don't get that their lack of ideas and complete lack of action is going to make November more painful for them than 2010.

    People ignored all the lies spread about Walker, they saw through the whining and crying, and no matter what the biased liberal media says, it has shown how obsolete and out of touch it has become.

    I don't care who runs against Tammy what's her name, she going to loose in a big way.
  7. Dick Dastardly
    Report Abuse
    Dick Dastardly - July 29, 2012 8:23 am
    I see it like this. 1st choice, Newman. 2nd choice Hovde. 3rd choice, Tommy. At least Tommy is better than Tammy.

    DD
  8. moyboy25
    Report Abuse
    moyboy25 - July 28, 2012 7:55 pm
    The Madison leftist must be worried to even write an article like this. Who do the leftist have? A left of Falk inside the Madison beltway liberal in Baldwin. Laughable outside Madison. Apparently these people learned absolutely nothing in the governor race. The populous outside of govt employees WEAC and the hate America crowd is awake now thanks to the rioting at our capitol last year. It's going to be another smack down. And to think these people think of themselves as intellectuals?? Laughable in deed.
  9. BananaSplitz
    Report Abuse
    BananaSplitz - July 28, 2012 6:57 pm
    I don't recognize him anymore. Kinda sad.
  10. BananaSplitz
    Report Abuse
    BananaSplitz - July 28, 2012 6:57 pm
    Nicely played and spot on.
  11. BillTwain
    Report Abuse
    BillTwain - July 28, 2012 6:49 pm
    Between Tommy's record as a give-em-everything Governor, (damn the budget, we can kite that later), and that fact that he's 70 (can he even be serious - it's a 6 year term, do the math?), that ought to deep six him in any rational race. But this isn't a rational race. This doesn't say much for the Republican candidates, as is pretty well covered above.

    What a joke. Hardly even a pretense of care of governing, just wrecking, including the economy.

    I don't think he's mean enough for this 'hood. Take your money Tommy, and retire to Miami with the high rollers and golf for free.
  12. RichardSRussell
    Report Abuse
    RichardSRussell - July 28, 2012 6:05 pm
    The fact that you even have to ask whether Tommy Thompson's record might hurt him in the GOP primary speaks volumes about how completely screwed up the Wisconsin Republican Party has become.
  13. jimatmadison
    Report Abuse
    jimatmadison - July 28, 2012 6:01 pm
    As governor, Tommy Thompson was a drunken, on-the-take womanizer who politically often behaved in a practical, moderate manner. While I never voted for him, he did some good things for the state, including Badger Care and working to reform the welfare system.

    Now, he's apparently given up the practical, moderate approach and has turned hard right in an effort to win over the Tea Party fringers running the state GOP. I don't know if he's given up his other past characteristics as well.

    Yet, sadly for the GOP, he's the best they have. Eric Hovde is a carpetbagging vulture capitalist who has never voted in a Wisconsin general election for the US Senate. Now he wants to hold the position he's never even cared enough about to get to the polls for?

    That tells me that Hovde doesn't care about political policy for Wisconsinites, and is just looking to further rig the system to benefit himself.

    Fitzgerald is rightly viewed as a radical ideologue, and Neumann is just scratching his biennial gotta-run-for-something itch.

We provide a valuable forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on posted articles. But there are rules: Don't promote products or services, impersonate other site users, register multiple accounts, threaten or harass others, post vulgar, abusive, obscene or sexually oriented language. Don't post content that defames or degrades anyone. Don't repost copyrighted material; link to it. In other words, stick to the topic and play nice. Report abuses by clicking the button. Users who break the rules will be banned from commenting. We no longer issue warnings.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

You might also like
×