Scott Walker wants to salvage school accountability bill

2014-01-30T05:25:00Z Scott Walker wants to salvage school accountability billMOLLY BECK | Wisconsin State Journal | | 608-252-6135

Gov. Scott Walker said Wednesday he is working to salvage a school accountability bill that has been pulled from a scheduled vote after encountering resistance from both public and private school advocates.

Sen. Luther Olsen, chairman of the Senate Education Committee, said Wednesday that he canceled a Thursday vote on the bill because “we don’t have enough votes to pass it.”

Olsen, R-Ripon, told reporters he did not know if the bill would return this year.

The current version of the bill, first introduced last fall, would revamp the state’s report card system, require persistently low-performing public schools to close or be turned into independent charter schools, and subject voucher schools to state oversight, among other things.

Walker said Wednesday he is committed to having a school accountability bill passed this session and that his office has begun talking with legislative leaders about a compromise. He said the Olsen legislation could serve as a starting point for the discussion, but he didn’t have specific changes in mind.

“I’m not pushing for or against closing or not closing public or choice schools,” Walker said. “I just think anything that’s in there should be as equal as possible so we’re applying the same types of standards.”

Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, R-Rochester, is still hopeful that the bill will be voted on this session, spokeswoman Kit Beyer said Wednesday.

“We haven’t given up on it for this session,” Beyer said.

Olsen unveiled proposed changes to the bill on Monday. After that, many proponents of public schools and supporters of private schools and school choice said they were unhappy with many of the changes, but for different reasons.

The bill would make several changes to the state’s K-12 school accountability system, including assigning schools letter grades, and would change the criteria by which schools are judged. In addition, schools that receive an F for three consecutive years, or a combination of Ds and Fs with weak growth scores for five consecutive years, would be closed or turned over to a private charter management organization. Eligible organizations would have to operate existing charter schools with better test results than district schools.

Public charter schools with similar poor performance would have their charters revoked and wouldn’t be allowed to participate in the voucher program if they reopen as private schools.

The proposal also would require testing for taxpayer-subsidized students at private voucher schools while barring the lowest-performing schools from enrolling new voucher students. Participating private schools also could test all students for accountability purposes.

Matt Kussow of the Wisconsin Council of Religious and Independent Schools said the bill should find a way to ensure any letter grade given to a private schools in the state’s voucher system reflects the achievement of all students in that school and also allow public and private schools to use whichever nationally standardized test they feel works best for their school.

Sen. Paul Farrow, R-Village of Pewaukee, said Wednesday he’d like to see the bill create an “accountability council” that would make recommendations for the formula used to grade schools. He also said he had concerns over how students at voucher schools would be tested, and if there’s a way to get a more accurate picture of how voucher schools compare to other schools.

“The complexity of a solid accountability bill is going to take a lot of work,” Farrow said. He also said he did not know if the bill would be ready for a vote this session.

Dan Rossmiller of the Wisconsin Association of School Boards said his members were concerned that the bill allows private schools receiving vouchers to pick which test they use to assess their students. “Their evaluation might be based on a completely different test than public schools’ would be based on and that’s not apples to apples,” he said.

Public school officials have also expressed concern that low-performing schools would have to be closed or turned over to charter school operators.

Olsen said Wednesday he was trying to create a report card system that treats all taxpayer-funded schools equally. “One of our main principles is that the report cards have to be fair,” he said.

He added that some of the choice schools can have their own standardized tests, so he’s not sure that’s a fair measure.

Rossmiller also said school board members across the state are very concerned about having an accountability system that applies the same rules and consequences for all schools equally.

“The bill would begin to have an effect on public schools generally within three years and in Milwaukee, in 1 year, and it doesn’t look like anything serious would happen to any voucher schools until maybe 2020 or 2021,” he said.

Rossmiller also said the bill’s proposal to require school boards to close persistently low-performing schools or turn them over to charter managers could have unintended consequences.

“This is really an unproven and uncharted area and I don’t know what unintended consequences there could be but I assume there will be a lot,” he said, noting that many schools that would fall into the affected category are high schools. “That tends to focus the problem at the high school level, and I think the proponents of this proposal have to be very careful that they don’t create a very chaotic situation.”

Betsy Kippers, president of the Wisconsin Education Association Council and a teacher in Racine, said Wednesday that lawmakers must go back to the drawing board.

“It just needs to be redone,” she said. “This is a total re-do of the bill. There needs to be a public hearing if it goes anywhere.”

Kippers said the bill should hold private schools that are receiving taxpayer dollars to the same standards as public schools. She also took issue with the bill’s requirement that the lowest-performing 5 percent of schools in the state automatically receive an F rating through the 2018-19 school year.

“Would we allow a teacher to say, ‘By the way, 5 percent of you must fail by the rules’?” Kippers said. “This is going to punish schools who do not have a long-term history of 2 years or more of failing.”

— State Journal reporters

Matthew DeFour and Mary

Spicuzza and the Associated Press contributed to this report.

Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(4) Comments

  1. Mr Mellow
    Report Abuse
    Mr Mellow - February 01, 2014 7:15 pm
    We live in a country where big corporations spy on our communications (AT&T, Verizon, Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, etc.) and monitor our financial transactions (VISA, Mastercard, AmEx, Citibank, JPMorgan Chase Bank, Bank of America, the credit rating agencies, etc.)

    We live in a country where big corporations own most news and entertainment organizations, controlling what is and isn't presented on TV, radio, movie theaters, and the Internet.

    We live in a country where, post-Citizens United, big corporations and their wealthy owners can, and do, freely spend billions bankrolling national and state political campaigns, making their dollars and their media more important than our voices and our votes,

    We live in a country where big corporations employ front organizations like ALEC to secretly craft and push 'model' legislation that their corporate funded politicians pass for them, (including voting restrictions, partisan redistricting, etc.), to lock their politicians into power.

    One thing big corporations do not yet control is the public educational system, which they are relentlessly attempting to subvert and replace it with a privately run for profit schools that use taxpayer money to teach our children using on corporate defined curriculums.

    Strong local control is the enemy of corporate control. Informed voters and high voter turnout are the enemy of corporate control. Limits on campaign contribution amounts are the enemy of corporate control. Mandatory public disclosure on who is giving money to which politicians for what purposes is the enemy of corporate control.

    It's time for voters to see which parties and politicians are supporting big corporations and the rich -- and vote them out of office. While we still can.
  2. Mr Mellow
    Report Abuse
    Mr Mellow - February 01, 2014 6:39 pm
    Year after year Walker and the Republicans have pushed expansion of school privatization, without any meaningful accountability standards. Only now that he is facing re-election does he seem motivated to get something passed.

    Why? Because he is politically vulnerable on this issue.

    Take the case of the Milwaukee charter school that recently closed in the middle of the night. The couple who ran the school disappeared down to Florida with $200,000 the state paid them last fall to educate sixty-six students. These kids got dumped on the street halfway through the school year, with only one of them able to meet math and reading standards. Altogether, this 'school' received $2M in state tax-payer money.

    And there are other examples of fraud, malfeasance, and failure.
  3. array1
    Report Abuse
    array1 - January 30, 2014 1:25 pm
    Automatically replace poor performing public schools with a charter?? What about all those kids attending public schools that a charter would never accept? Where do they go? Republican brilliance I say
  4. nokoch
    Report Abuse
    nokoch - January 30, 2014 9:38 am
    First they lower the standards of learning in schools as to not make some kids feel bad. We have kids in school that don't give a care about learning. They do not care who is in charge, they do not respect anyone including their parents. Parents rights, teachers rights etc. have been taken away. The attitude is go ahead touch me and I'll call the cops for abuse.
    Second, and if you do some digging you will find that this public schools to private and charter schools is all what the Koch brothers want so they can control what your child learns. ( If I teach them what I want them to learn then I have control of them. Dummy them down.) And you know if you dig into the ALEC agendas you will find it and you know who all belong to ALEC.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

What's hot

Featured businesses