Esther Cepeda: The end of a proud second generation

2013-02-17T04:15:00Z Esther Cepeda: The end of a proud second generationESTHER CEPEDA | Chicago Sun-Times
February 17, 2013 4:15 am  • 

A Pew Research Center report — "Second-Generation Americans: A Portrait of the Adult Children of Immigrants" — recently verified something that has been the case throughout most of the nation's history: Children who grow up in this country become proud Americans.

Prepare for that to change.

I say this as a daughter of immigrants who, like roughly six out of 10 adult children of these newcomers, considers herself a "typical American." And like the overwhelming majority of second-gen Hispanics and Asians, I also believe the holiest of America's promises — that most people can get ahead if they're willing to work hard.

My peers and I didn't get this way just based on our parents' sunny dispositions. It was drilled into us by that great assimilation machine called public school. It's an education system that, as I learned while earning a graduate degree in education, has its roots in the mission to teach students patriotism and moral values.

Well, just forget about it these days. Morals are not something that schools want to touch with a 10-foot pole. Even the watered-down character programs — such as "Character Counts!" — seem to be going extinct in favor of more general campaigns that merely implore students to "Just Be Nice" or put their "Values in Action!"

And patriotism in school is dead.

Take this headline that came to me from the Education Action Group Foundation, which has been described as either a promoter of sensible education reform or a tool of the far-right fringe, "Radical education officials try to impose anti-American curriculum."

The e-blast claimed that Minnesota's education officials are proposing new social studies standards that would "no longer require students to learn about Martin Luther King Jr., the War on Terror, the Soviet Union or the importance of patriotism."

"Students would be required to learn about America's 'institutional racism,' 'the rise of big business,' and the problems posed by an 'unregulated capitalist economy.' In other words, some want to change the curriculum so history instructors teach children that the United States is a bad country with an evil past."

A level-headed independent thinker might wonder if such heated rhetoric is nothing more than the bizarre assertions of Ayn Rand-worshiping conservatives. But this doesn't mean there isn't some truth to it.

As a second-generation minority who came of age with similar peers in urban classrooms that resembled a mini-United Nations, I can say that my schools taught us to love our parents' adopted country with all our hearts. We grew up feeling as American as apple pie, even when we preferred comfort foods like leche flan or empanadas.

Today, as an ex-educator and the mother of two middle-school children attending schools staffed by left-leaning teachers trained more in the art of social justice than the science of pedagogy, I can tell you that when the current crop of school-age children of immigrants are grown, they may look at America as an imperialist, corporate-driven oppressor, not a source of pride.

In the name of inclusiveness, diversity, ethnic and gender studies, the education pendulum has swung to the point where, to read some of the worksheets that are given out as class work, you could forget that we are a nation molded by a group of enterprising founding fathers.

In the Howard Zinn "A People's History of the United States" version of the past that most new teachers seem to have been weaned on, America was instead developed by wealthy, slave-owning white males whose real claim to fame was capitalizing on the Native American genocide that Columbus and the first colonists took part in.

Don't laugh. This is not only how I've heard real teachers describe the roots of our nation, but almost exactly the terms in which social studies instruction was couched when I was going through formal teacher training.

We want to teach our students to think critically about their history, to be outraged at past wrongs. But too often, criticism is delivered to impressionable young minds with no real sense of historical context. The result is a constant drumbeat about how terrible America is.

In a nation where lawsuits are filed in order to avoid the supposed tyranny of having to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance, the prospects for inspiring patriotism in our children are bleak. Prepare for the next wave of second-generation Americans to be far less admiring of their country than their predecessors were.

Esther Cepeda writes for the Chicago Sun-Times.

Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(4) Comments

  1. Oscar
    Report Abuse
    Oscar - February 19, 2013 3:11 am
    America is what you make of it, I guess. Our whole standard of living depends upon paying others a penny a pound for their resources. If a foreign government objects, we put in another foreign government. But, for those that are here, our standard of living is high and our freedoms many. My wife's ancestors had slaves. You just have to be able to judge things fairly and accurately. You can't control the world, but by having a personal code of conduct, you can control you.
  2. scorp
    Report Abuse
    scorp - February 17, 2013 9:23 pm
    The most recent report opined that the intelligence of the species is DECREASING . Whether that is a result of climate warming,environmental pollution , or mere genetic pool manipulation ,the trend is downward. The more intelligent of the species in US and Europe have failed to reproduce based upon economic factors and new societal mores while the established intellectually "poor" and some minorities are encouraged to reproduce by financial benefits. Although regression to the mean should even things, such theory is overwhelmed by the pure numbers game . The "bell curve" is being skewed .
    Therefore , one cannot blame the school systems or the value forfeiture of society ,the kids are just not as smart. However,the focus and intensity requirement for success has been destroyed by public schools and media by promoting political correctness as the primary value. Self -esteem promotions by focusing on "equality in performance" and rewards for mediocrity ,are great for the "warm and fuzzy" ,but bear an inverse relationship to success in the real world.
    Yes , immigrants with educated parents and a focus on success will make it even today, but too many come here for only the entitlements and menial jobs.
  3. geo_
    Report Abuse
    geo_ - February 17, 2013 8:23 am
    So Esther, you're saying America wasn't founded by slave owning rich white males, you're saying America didn't give small pox laden blankets to Native Americans, you're saying America didn't go to war over a bunch of lies just to gain access to cheap oil at the cost of over 4700 American lives, over 100,000 Iraqi lives and an unfunded 3 trillion dollars. Just where did you go to school?
  4. toby
    Report Abuse
    toby - February 17, 2013 7:16 am
    I spent 35 yrs in public education, & I get really sick of this right mantra that we in public education do not teach values have removed God from our schools & aren't patriotic. We started evry day with the Pledge of Allegance, we had ae extensive character ed program that was about teaching fairness, honesty, perserverance,resposibilty, respect,citizenship, etc. we as educators worked this into our daily routines with our students. We always brought in vetreans on Memorial Day, Veterans Day assemblies.

We provide a valuable forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on posted articles. But there are rules: Don't promote products or services, impersonate other site users, register multiple accounts, threaten or harass others, post vulgar, abusive, obscene or sexually oriented language. Don't post content that defames or degrades anyone. Don't repost copyrighted material; link to it. In other words, stick to the topic and play nice. Report abuses by clicking the button. Users who break the rules will be banned from commenting. We no longer issue warnings.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

What's hot

Featured businesses

Get weekly ads via e-mail

Vote! Today's poll


With Scott Walker now an official presidential candidate, how far will he go?

View Results