Schools need boost, budget needs balance

2013-03-03T05:00:00Z Schools need boost, budget needs balanceWisconsin State Journal editorial
March 03, 2013 5:00 am  • 







Freezing public school spending in Wisconsin would be a mistake, given previous cuts and rising costs.

That’s the most glaring problem with Gov. Scott Walker’s two-year, $68 billion state budget proposal.

The Republican governor also stalls his considerable progress toward an honest and truly balanced budget. Having slain a giant budget gap two years ago, Walker shouldn’t be backtracking even a bit.

The Legislature has some fixing to do.

Yet some of Walker’s priorities are strong, including:

• His support — and flexibility — for higher education. Wisconsin would go back to spending more on universities than prisons, and workforce development would get a boost. Technical colleges would get new money linked to graduation rates, job placement and training workers in high-demand fields.

• A special fund to lure more investment capital for young and innovative companies. The fund is an important step for encouraging job and income growth for workers across Wisconsin.

• More autonomy for public charter schools. These schools are supposed to try new things. So giving them more freedom makes sense, as long as local school boards or some other public entity can stop charters if they’re not working after typically five years.

Public charter schools are different than private and religious voucher schools, which need more accountability to taxpayers before any expansion. Walker said last week he would seek legislation requiring all schools that receive public dollars to be graded under the state’s new report card system.

That’s a good start. Money also should be tied to performance for voucher schools if that’s how public schools are going to be treated.

Overall, the governor has proposed a small increase in state aid to public schools. The catch is the new money is dedicated to holding down property taxes, rather than helping education.

This follows two years of deep cuts in state aid. To offset much of the reduction, many school districts required teachers and other employees to pay more toward their health and pension benefits.

Walker’s strict limits on collective bargaining, while controversial, also gave school districts more freedom to change health insurance providers.

But those savings have been tapped by most districts. And school spending can’t be frozen forever.

The Legislature should allow schools some reasonable growth — something Sens. Mike Ellis, R-Neenah, and Luther Olsen, R-Ripon, are proposing — even if that threatens plans to trim income taxes.

One of Walker’s biggest accomplishments over the last two years was the elimination of a stubborn budget gap, called the “structural deficit,” that set up future state budgets for shortfalls.

But the governor’s latest budget request is projected to create a $188 million hole in two years. The governor and Legislature should remember how much better it feels to budget with a small surplus than it does to lurch from shortfall to shortfall.

Good budgeting practices should expand further, not shrink.





Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(2) Comments

  1. spooky tooth
    Report Abuse
    spooky tooth - March 03, 2013 6:16 pm
    Charter schools are supposed to try new things? You mean the way public schools operated before they were required to teach to the test?

    If the State Journal believes that Public Schools are failing, then write editorials about Charter Schools or even Private Schools taking vouchers for all the kids that are failing so they can prove they are better. If Charter or Private Schools can take these failing kids and do better than they can have our tax dollars.

    For Walker and the people that pull his string, this has never been about the kids and always about privatizing public schools. Same thing with SS, medicare, medicaid and everything in between, it's about privatizing. There's a lot of money to be made by a select few.

    Maybe when they put tolls on all roads leading into Madison Newspapers you'll wish you said something.
  2. athabasca
    Report Abuse
    athabasca - March 03, 2013 5:24 am
    Two things: 1) the structural deficit is by no means "eliminated." Numbers from budget-wonk extraordinaire Sen. Kathleen Vinehout: "The GAP gap – the mismatch between money coming in and money going out using Generally Accepted Accounting Principles – increases in the 2013-2015 budget from $2,211,006,000 to a projected $2,644,600,000." And Gov. Walker has added a billion to Wisconsin's long term debt, and failed to pay debt payments coming due in 2011 and 2012.

    Second: The proposal to "report-card" voucher schools is a fig-leaf, a gesture that would have no meaning for the next six years while they'd be allowed to ramp up without actually being graded! Real accountability would include having to abide by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, for very basic starters. We shouldn't even be thinking about handing out special needs vouchers that don't come with IDEA rights and protections!
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Activate your subscription and gain access to a whole new world

What's hot

Vote! Today's poll


Do you support right-to-work legislation?

View Results